
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)I did some web research on this book. Some folks, who were around in the sixties, say that Tegner adapted the Kung Fu material in this book from "Chinese Karate Kung-Fu, Original Sil Lum System" by T. Y. Wong and James Yimm Lee (friend of Bruce Lee). Here is an old quote from an online forum:"As for the late V. E. Christensen (the guy demonstrating in the BruceTegner book "Kung Fu & Tai Chi, Chinese Karate & Classical Exercises"), a former Tegner student once claimed that Christensen had trained in Los Angeles with Ark Yuey Wong. I do believe he was mistaken though. It's understandable, since the Kung Fu uniform Christensen wears is the same kind that Ark Wong wore (and rather distinctive), but if one compares the contents of the Tegner book with the contents of T.Y. Wong's Sil Lum book, it is VERY apparent that everything in Tegner's book was adapted from Wong's book.
That's not to say that they are exact copies. Certain things which are only mentioned in Wong's book are expanded upon in Tegner's volume to create several basic, beginning-level forms, while the last two forms (which are just slight variations of the ones in Wong's book) are almost move-for-move the same, with certain changes, possibly to avoid copyright infringements."Tegner, after all, was a Judo blackbelt and champion -- not a Kung-Fu expert. T. Y. Wong had a school in San Francisco during the sixties. His style is said to be rare in the America (that is why another reviewer doesn't recognize it). Wong's book was released in 1961 and is one of the first English language books on Kung Fu. It seems to be something of a collector's item. It is hard to find and expensive. I am glad Tegner copped the material from the Wong book so that I can have a look at it (cheap). When I was a kid (60s), Tegner helped introduce America to the Asian martial arts when there wasn't much available. His books were a staple in school libraries. For that alone, he deserves credit.
The Tai Chi material in this book is good. In his introduction to Tai Chi, Tegner states, "do not worry too much about little variations of posture; the main thing is to capture the attitude and essence of the movements. If you do that, you get the benefits of the exercise." This advice is similar to the advice given in the Official Manual of the People's Republic of China (see "Knocking At The Gate of Life" by Chang). The PRC manual even recommends making up your own Tai Chi-like movements if you can't learn traditional Tai Chi.
Reviewers who give this book a low rating seem to be most upset with Tegner's comments (in the introduction) concerning the philosophical and mystical aspects of the Chinese martial arts as well as his words of caution concerning the extravagant claims about the health benefits of Tai Chi. In the Kung Fu chapter, Tegner wrote, "it is my feeling that ch'i can only be interpreted as confidence, determination or fighting spirit. Unless it is taken to mean that, I do not think that it can have any significance for the Western student." In the Tai Chi chapter, Tegner states, "Tai Chi is good exercise and it deserves to be rescued from the bad reputation of cure-all quackery." Tegner had a common sense (Westernized) approach to the Asian martial arts. He taught that it is possible to practice these martial arts for exercise, sport, and self-defense skills without embracing the philosophical/religious traditions which helped give rise to them. He was a bit of a debunker. Those aspects of the Asian martial arts that he debunked (the extravagant claims and the mystical stuff) is what attracts many people to the Asian martial arts in the first place. So, obviously, he is the victim of anger and ridicule in martial arts circles. But, his books work for me.
The material in this book makes for good exercise. In Tegner's words, Tai Chi promotes "...flexibility, coordination, poise, balance and body-control..." And, "the Kung Fu form, done with maximum vigor, could be the complimentary activity to give you a complete exercise program."
If you are looking for a good book on self-defense you will be better served to buy "Bruce Tegner's Complete Book of Self-Defense" and "Self-Defense Nerve Centers & Pressure Points." On the other hand, if you want to leap twenty feet in the air or walk up the sides of buildings, like you see in the Kung Fu movies, this is not your book.
Click Here to see more reviews about:
Kung Fu and Tai Chi: Chinese Karate and Classical Exercises
Click here for more information about Kung Fu and Tai Chi: Chinese Karate and Classical Exercises